WHO, OR WHAT, IS A 'PALESTINIAN'? A HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE |
||||
![]() |
||||
| EMAIL |
MESSAGE
BOARD |
HOME |
SEARCH |
MULTIMEDIA |
| GUESTBOOK |
SUPPORT
ISRAEL |
LIST
OF ARTICLES |
NEWSLETTERS |
POWERPOINTS |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
||
EDITORS NOTE; IF YOU TAKE THE TIME TO READ THE ACTUAL ARTICLES, SOME OF YOU MAY FIND SOME OF THEM VERY OFFENSIVE. THE PURPOSE OF THIS SERIES OF ARTICLES IS TO PROVIDE A HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE OF HOW PALESTINIAN, AND THE OTHER KEYWORDS, HAS EVOLVED OVER THE YEARS. 2000 Pal·es·tine: Often called "the Holy Land.". : A historical region of southwest Asia at the eastern end of the Mediterranean Sea and roughly coextensive with modern Israel and the West Bank. Occupied since prehistoric times, it has been ruled by Hebrews, Egyptians, Romans, Byzantines, Arabs, and Turks. A British League of Nations mandate oversaw the affairs of the area from 1920 until 1948, when Israel declared itself a separate state and the West Bank territory was occupied by Jordan. The West Bank was subsequently annexed (1950) by Jordan and occupied (1967) by Israel. In 1988 the Palestine Liberation Organization under Yasir Arafat declared its intention of forming an Arab state of Palestine, probably including the West Bank, the Gaza Strip, and the Arab sector of Jerusalem. The Palestinians achieved limited self-rule in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank in 1993 and 1994. Palestinian: adj : of or relating to the area of Palestine and its inhabitants; "Palestinian guerrillas" n : a descendant of the Arabs who inhabited Palestine The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition Copyright © 2000 1988 Palestinian: Not listed Barnhart Dictionary of Etymology 1983 Palestinian: n 1. A native or inhabitant of Palestine 2. Also called Palestinian Arab, an Arab formerly living in Palestine who advocates the establishment of an Arab homeland. Random House Dictionary of the English Language 2nd Edition 1976 PALESTINE: n A territory on the eastern coast of the Mediterranean, the country of the Jews in Biblical times. 2. part of this territory, exclusive of Trans-Jordan and parts of Syria under a British mandate after WW1: area 10157 sq miles, population 1,900,000, capital Jerusalem, divided into separate independent Arab and Jewish states by action of the United Nation in 1947: cf Israel: biblical name Canaan, also called Holy Land PALESTINIAN: adj, of Palestine or its people. n. a native or inhabitant of Palestine 1976 edition Webster's New World Dictionary College Edition 1967 Palestinian: adj of or pertaining to Palestine. No noun definition listed Random House Dictionary of the English language 1963 Palestinian: n a native or inhabitant of Palestine: Israel Webster's Third International Edition But if we check the 1910 Webster dictionary we get Palestinian (a.) Alt. of Palestinean Palestinian (a.) Of or pertaining to Palestine. I have researched numerous newspaper articles, covering over 150 years, on their use of the word "Palestinian". Following are the headlines, with links to photocopies of the actual articles. Ames Daily Tribune (Ames, Iowa) Appleton Post Crescent (Appleton, Wisconsin) Atlanta Constitution, The (Atlanta, Georgia), Bennington Evening Banner, The (Bennington, Vermont) Berkshire Evening Eagle, The (Pittsfield, Berkshire, Massachusetts) Bluefield Daily Telegraph (Bluefield, West Virginia) Bridgeport Telegram, The (Bridgeport, Connecticut) Cambridge Jeffersonian (Cambridge, Ohio) Charleston Daily Mail, The (Charleston, West Virginia) Chronicle Telegram (Elyria, Ohio) Coshocton Tribune (Coshocton, Ohio) Daily Herald (Delphos, Ohio) Deming Headlight (Deming, New Mexico) Edwardsville Intelligencer (Edwardsville, Illinois) Frederick Post (Frederick, Maryland) Fort Wayne Journal-Gazette, The (Fort Wayne, Indiana) Gettysburg Times (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) Helena Independent, The (Helena, Montana) Indiana Evening Gazette (Indiana, Pennsylvania) Indianapolis Star, The (Indianapolis, Indiana) Iowa City Press Citizen (Iowa City, Iowa) Iowa Recorder, The (Greene, Iowa) Jackson Sentinel, The (Maquoketa, Iowa) Long Beach Independent (Long Beach, California) Mansfield News (Mansfield, Ohio) Marion Star, The (Marion, Ohio) Montana Standard (Butte, Montana) Nevada State Journal (Reno, Nevada) New York Times, (New York, New York), News (Frederick, Maryland) Olean Democrat (Olean, New York) Petersburg Index, The (Petersburg, Virginia) Reno Evening Gazette (Reno, Nevada) Sheboygan Press (Sheboygan, Wisconsin) Stevens Point Daily Journal (Stevens Point, Wisconsin) Times Recorder, The (Zanesville, Ohio) Traverse City Record Eagle (Traverse City, Michigan) Trenton Times, The (Trenton, New Jersey) Wichita Daily Times (Wichita Falls, Texas) 1868-1931
The Petersburg Index,
Petersburg Virginia 27 May
1868 FEAST OF PENTECOST.But the significance of the festival does not end here, but takes a wider scope, for whilst its origin and and institution in one sense are exhibited to us in Scripture, there is another and loftier circumstance connected with its observance, which concerns not Israelites alone, but all mankind, which does not limit itself to Palestinian agriculture and a successful reaping of the harvest, but essentially regards the everlasting weal of the whole human race. 1882
Reno Evening Gazette Reno Nevada 14 December 1882 CHANUKKAH Wednesday evening the Jewish festival of Chanukkah was commenced in the houses of worship and residences in the larger cities. This feast, beginning with the 25th day in the 9th month (kislav) has eight days and is celebrated in commemoration of the heroic deeds of the priestly family of Hasmoneans, also called Maccabees, after the surname of their greatest hero Judah,,,who secured the freedom of their religious practices and the independence of the Palestinian Jews. 1888
Olean Democrat Olean New York 02 August 1888 RELIGIOUS GLEANINGS Mr Lawrence Oliphant, of literary fame, but also noted for his advocacy of Palestinian colonization, says that Baron Edmund Rothschild's pet colony cost him 50,000 (pounds). Mr Oliphants advice is “send nothing to Palestine but save and collect money for the future and its great changes- a contingency which may be more immediate than may be generally supposed.” 1890
Freeborn County Standard Albert Lea Minnesota 20 March 1890 AN IMPORTANT DISCOVERY If, as is said, and we are not yet in a position to speak of it as more than a rumor, the new codex resembles the Sinaitic not only in additional books, that are appended to it- the Epistle of Barnabus and the Shepherd of Hermas- but also in the peculiarities of text, it would seem to be almost a duplicate of the Sinaitic, both forming, perhaps, part of an edition issued for the common use of the Palestinian church. 1897
1. Daily Herald Delphos Ohio 21 July 1897 CURRENT MISCELLANY Mrs Lewis, who discovered the manuscripts of the gospels in a Syriac convent on Mount Sinai, has been exploring the convent again in company with her sister, Mrs Gibson, and has examined two Palestinian Syriac service books of the twelfth century, written in the dialect supposed to have spoken by Christ. 2. The Atlanta Constitution Atlanta Georgia 19 May, 1897 AMERICAN HEBREWS AND ZIONISM "We are Jews by religion; we are a race with a distinct religious mission. For the rest we are identified with the welfare, the greatness and progress of the people with whom we live, and we give the lie to those who say that in our heart of hearts we are PALESTINIANS." In
the first five examples, we have
PALESTINIAN being used as an adjective, as the 1910 Webster and the
2000 American Heritage dictionaries define. And all five examples refer
to either Christian or Jewish contexts. descendant of the Arabs who inhabited Palestine. 1900
The Trenton
Times Trenton New Jersey 04 March 1901 ISRAEL
OBSERVES FEAST OF PURIMWe're in the 20th century now.
Surely we are about to find some more of those elusive "PALESTINIANS".
The Atlanta Constitution Atlanta Georgia 14 October 1900 THE SCRIPTURES IN THE LIGHT OF RECENT ARCHAELOGICAL DISCOVERIES, "The expedition of the four kings from the east against the five PALESTINIAN kings is confirmed..." 1901 The local Zionist will have a mass meeting on Purim night at their hall on South Warren Street, where prominent speakers will address the audience, and Palestinian wine will be served to the public. So far we
have only one use of PALESTINIAN as a noun, and every example
I could find, except one, uses PALESTINIAN in a Jewish context.
1903
1. Bluefield Daily Telegraph Bluefield West Virginia 16 JANUARY 1903 ADVERTISEMENT THE JEWS DO NOT WANT ZION RESESTABLISHED IN PALESTINE The greatest blessing in disguise that ever happened to Israel was the overthrow of the Palestinian kingdom and its dispersion throughout the world 2. Delphos Daily Herald Delphos, Ohio 16 October 1903 NEW COLONY FOR JEWS "We are still Palestinians. The creation of a community in Palestine is our ultimate goal, and from that purpose we will never depart." 1906
1. The
Atlanta Constitution Atlanta Georgia 29 January 1906 UNITARIAN,"Jesus was a prophet, not an organizer. He was a PALESTINIAN Emerson, a truth scatterer, not a creed-builder" 2. New York Times, New York New York 14 APRIL 1906 ACTS OF THE APOSTLES ..while the spirit of the author's later times breathes through his periods and the interest of his own age appear, his work does present to us, in its main outlines, a fairly authentic and exceedingly precious account of the years and deeds of the persons wherein and whereby the Palestinian message of good tidings become a gospel for and in the whole world of men. 3. Washington Post Washington District Of Columbia 24 June 1906 WHAT HEBREWS HAVE ACCOMPLISHED "They not only became a commercial people, but post PALESTINIAN business forced them to be middlemen in every department" 4. The Fort Wayne Journal-Gazette Fort Wayne Indiana 16 SEPTEMBER 1906 EXPLORATION OF FORTY YEARS IN PALESTINE Here traces of all periods of Palestinian civilization, from the Maccabean age - the castle of Simon Maccabaeus having been discovered- the the neolithic age... 1911
The
Atlanta Constitution Atlanta Georgia 19 JULY
1914The
Washington
Post Washington District Of Columbia 17 January 1911
PREHISTORIC PURE FOOD
"Dating back to the period of King Ahab, fully 900 BC, these inscriptions are considered to be one of the greatest finds of the Harvard PALESTINIAN expedition..." "the first PALESTINIAN records of this nature to be found" 1914 MEMORIAL MEETING PLANNED FOR DR HERTZEL Already through the aid and the work of the Zionists over 100,000 Jews are living in the Palestinian colonies... 1915
1. The
Atlanta
Constitution Atlanta Georgia 8 MAY
1918 JUDEANS ARE ALLIES, SAYS ITTAMAR BEN AVI1. The
Washington
Post Washington District Of Columbia 11 March 1915 ZIONISTS GIVE
MUCH AID,
"We
believe that such action,
taken at this time, would do much toward giving stability to the whole
work of PALESTINIAN relief, not only in these troubling times, but in a
more traquil future as well."
2. Indiana Messenger Indiana Pennsylvania 08 December 1915 DIVIDED INTO SIX RACES, "To the northern branch belong the Assyrian and Aramean(or Syrian) and the PALESTINIAN (Hebrew and Phoenician)." 1916 Fort Wayne
Journal
Gazette
Fort Wayne Indiana 24 January 1916 PLAN CONGRESS TO SETTLE STATUS OF
JEWS IN ALL THE NATIONS. Sounds like a grand scheme...
"Other resolutions presented to the convention dealt with the PALESTINIAN question and the problem of caring for Jewish immigrants to the United States." 1918 You owe allegiance to only one flag- the American. And no one knows it better than I, a Palestinian. 2. The Coshocton Tribune, Coshocton Ohio 18 July 1918 SOCIAL JUSTICE IN PALESTINE, "Some time must elapse before it will be possible to organize a self governing PALESTINIAN state and put into effect the plan outlined." 3. Oxnard Courier Oxnard California 30 JULY 1918 HEBREWS FORMING PALESTINE LEGION "There are scores of Russians in Los Angelos who are warm Zionists...partly because of the Palestinian objective. The Allied cause is now their cause." 1919 1. The Decatur
Daily Review Decatur Illinois 04 September 1919 BIG MEET
IN
CHICAGO
we find, "Dr Chaym Weitzman,...a member of the PALESTINIAN Commission" 2. The Decatur Review Decatur Illinois 23 September 1919 JEWISH NEW YEAR "A few days after the Day of Atonement, the Feast of Succoth or Tabernacles is celebrated during a period of eight days, in commemoration of the ancient PALESTINIAN harvest festival and the wanderings of the Israelites through the wilderness." 1920 1. The
Chronicle
Telegram Elyria Ohio
05 April 1920 ST ANDREWS EPISCIPAL CHURCH
"The Good Friday offerings amounted to some $35 to be used for relief work in the PALESTINIAN world" 2. Iowa City Press Citizen Iowa City Iowa 26 November 1920 JEWS MEET TO WORK OUT PLANS FOR PALESTINE, "The supporters of this viewpoint regard the organization as committed to the control by Jews for Jewish people of PALESTINIAN undertakings" 3. The Chronicle Telegram Elyria Ohio 30 NOVEMBER 1920 NEAR EAST ATTRACTS UNITED STATES TRADE The American council at Jerusalem sends the following information regarding the trade outlook in the Holy Land. “One of the Palestinian ports will in the future capture a larger part of the trade of the Mediterranean and Western Asia from the Hellespont to Bab-El- Mandeb. 1921 "The American University in Beirut, Syria is the only place open to PALESTINIANS seeking higher education" 2. Nevada State Journal Reno Nevada 5 JUNE 1921 ZIONIST DISTRICTS TO HAVE CONVENTION American leaders, headed by Judge Julian W Mack of New York, contend that the activities of the Keren Hayesod, or Palestine Foundation Fund, be limited to a donation fund, to be paid to the executive of the World Zionist Organization, to be expended by the latter body only in Palestine and only in accordance with the Palestinian budget. 3. The Wichita Daily Times,Wichita Falls, Texas 19 DECEMBER 1921 OBSERVANCE OF JEWISH 'FEAST OF DEDICATION' TO START NEXT SUNDAY Under the leadership of the aged priest and his sons, of whom Judah is the most famous, the Palestinian Jews threw themselves against the armies of Syria. 1922
1. The
Kingsport
Times Kingsport
Tennessee 14 March ARABIAN PEOPLE ARE MORE HOPEFUL,
"Their delegates have roamed Europe in an endeavor to influence public opinion in favor of Palestine for the PALESTINIANS" AFTER ALL THESE YEARS WE HAVE PALESTINIAN
BEING USED BY ARABS TO DESCRIBE THEMSELVES. AND DO YOU NOTICE
THAT THEY ARE ALREADY ATTEMPTING TO STEAL THE WORD FOR THEMSELVES.
2. The Kingsport Times Kingsport Tennesse 1 April ARABS CLASH WITH ZIONIST FANCTIONS we get a glimpse into the ongoing clash that is still occurring in Israel today, 3. The Kingsport Times Kingsport Tennessee 12 April AMERICAN TOURISTS INFEST PALESTINE (how is that for a title?), "It is estimated that PALESTINIANS will as a result benefit financially by a sum of not less than $500,000" 4. News Frederick Maryland 11 DECEMBER 1922 FEAST OF DEDICATION These epochal events in the stirring year 168-165 BC recount the valor and heroism of a few Palestinian Jews... 1923
Reno
Evening Gazette Reno Nevada 6
NOVEMBER 1923 THE DISCOVERIES AT BEISANThe Hebrew writers wrote quite fully upon this subject, but in the days when the Bible was written there existed traditions which were assumed to be known by all. To some extent these have been preserved in the Talmud, but not all by any means, and it is for this reason that every inscription, every roll of papyrus that alludes to the Palestinian inhabitants 1924
29 MAY
1924 WORLD RELIGIOUS NEWS1. Reno Evening
Gazette
Reno
Nevada 13 March 1924 HUSSEIN IS CHOSEN CALIPH BY MEN IN
PALESTINE
"A great PALESTINIAN delegation composed of Muftis, cadis, ulemas, sheiks and other notables took part" 2. The Chronicle Telegram Elyria Ohio 29 MAY 1924 WORLD RELIGIOUS NEWS "The ruins of an old synagogue in Caperneum, the PALESTINIAN village where Jesus first preached" 3. The Washington Post Washington District Of Columbia 15 July 1924 ENTIRE TRIBE SEEKS TO RETURN "An entire tribe of Bedouins...has applied to the PALESTINIAN government to help it return to Judaism" 4. Indianapolis Star Indianapolis Indiana 06 JULY 1924 MOTOR TRANSPORT HIGHLY DEVELOPED reports Motor traffic, insignificant in Palestine before the war, is today more developed than in most European countries, due to the system of excellent roads constructed by the British government and the Palestine Foundation fund, according to a report from Jerusalem... Recently motor connections were established between Haifa, Palestine's principal seaport, and Baghdad...which has opened this vast hinterland to for the sale of Palestinian products. 5. The Washington Post Washington District Of Columbia 23 July 1924 PALESTINIANS OPPOSE ANGLO-HEDJAZ TREATIES, "PALESTINIAN ARABS" The ruins of an old synagogue in Capernaum, the Palestinian village where Jesus first preached to the Jews... 1925
1. The
Bridgeport
Telegram Bridgeport
Connecticut 10 December SYRIAN EMISSARY ASKS LEAGUE TO STOP BLOODSHED,
"One purports to be the copy of a dispatch to the League of Nations from the Syro-PALESTINIAN Congress " 2. Mansfield News Mansfield Ohio 31 DECEMBER 1925 'JESUS NO MYTH, BUT NO MORE THAN MAN, RABBI EXPLAINS IN SPEECH THAT CAUSED JEWS TO CRITICIZE The third thesis in Klaussner's book, ...is that Jesus was a man and a Jew, that he was a young Palestinian Jew. 1926 1. Coshocton Tribune Coshocton Ohio 23 FEBRUARY 1926 DAILY LETTER (JERUSALEM) BY G. AGRONSKY Elections to the second Jewish National Assembly were concluded with a decided victory to the Labourites... Equal suffrage was a unique feature of the polling, thirteen women candidates being returned. Palestinian women have as yet not learned how to use their vote... 2. The Helena Independent Helena Montana 21 March CONQUERING THE DESERT BETWEEN CAIRO AND JERUSALEM, "The trip was made in a Studebaker Big Six Duplex_Phaeton by E Hugh Cook, accompanied by Aref, a PALESTINIAN driver..." 3. The Chronicle Telegram Elyria Ohio 25 June REFORMS ORDERED BY MUSTAPHA KEMAL GIVING MODERN TOUCH TO NEAR EAST, "Constantinople has long been a marraige mart for wealthy PALESTINIAN Musselmens..." 1927 The
Helena
Independent Helena Montana 05 January PALESTINIANS HOLD
PRETENTIOUS PARTY,
"PALESTINIANS hold pretentious party" 1928 Pennsylvania Clearfield Clearfield
Progress 28 February PALESTINE'S
COMMON SIGHT SHOW WONDER OF GOSPEL,
"Yet these PALESTINIAN peasants represent a wonder of the world...These were the very sort of men who became the twelve apostles." 1929 1. Ironwood
Daily Globe Ironwood, Michigan 15 APRIL 1929 PARTY CRUISING DEAD SEA
LONG OVERDUE
"The missing numbered 12 in all, and included Harry Sacher, member of the PALESTINIAN Zionist executive committee" 2. Havre Daily News Havre Montana 14 JULY 1929 TWELVE FOUNDATION STONES, "Twelve foundation stones...were laid with old Jewish observance for the buildings which are to house the Jewish departments of the PALESTINIAN administration" 3. The Morning Call Laurel Mississippi 01 SEPTEMBER 1929 JEWISH EDITOR BLAMES BRITISH FOR ARAB RIOTS, "The impression was cred through a series of acts by the Palestine government, espcially with reference to the Wailing Wall incident that the PALESTINIAN officials were leaning towards the Arabs" 4. Appleton Post Crescent Appleton Wisconsin 13 SEPTEMBER 1929_LABOR ASKS JEWS OF OTHER PARTIES FOR HOLY WAR AID While the whole world is demanding the early restoration of order in the Holy Land, the English Labor Party has turned for aid to four prominent British Jews who are members of opposition parties... Lord Melchett has been much interested in the Zionist colonies in Palestine, and as a great businessman, has especially helped the attempts to establish Palestinian industries. 5. Ironwood Daily Globe Ironwood, Michigan 18 SEPTEMBER 1929 DEFENSE IN PALESTINE "In the events now taking place in the Near East...is to be found a solid justification of the supervision of PALESTINIAN affairs by a great power" 6. Appleton Post Crescent Appleton Wisconsin 12 October 1929 HUM OF INDUSTRY, "Major Tulloch, a British engineer, and Novemeysky, a PALESTINIAN chemist" 1930
1. Chronicle
Telegram Elyria Ohio 05 FEBRUARY 1930 CROWDS GROWING AT U.P.
CHURCH MEETINGS"This evening at 7:30 he will deal with another unconditional covenant that God made with the Jews, 'the PALESTINIAN Covenant'" 2. Chronicle Telegram Elyria Ohio 06 FEBRUARY 1930 MEEKER SPEAKS, "Reverend Meeker held the attention of
his audiance last night...from the start to the finish of his most
interesting address on the 'PALESTINIAN Covenant God Made With The Jews
and which He will fulfull in His time'"
3. Decatur Daily Review Decatur Illinois 02 DECEMBER 1930 PALESTINE AND PASSFIELD, "Furthermore, in his estimate of the number of acres of PALESTINIAN acres needed to support each Arab family, he stupidly included the tens of thousands of Arabs,-indeed I believe the hundreds of thousands of Arabs- who dwell in the desert and rarely come to the PALESTINIAN territory" 1931
1. The
Charleston Daily Mail Charleston West Virginia 22
FEBRUARY 1931VIEWS OF EINSTEIN ABOUT ZIONISM ARE PUBLISHED IN BOOK 'The real tragedy from recent Palestinian events is that “they have estranged the two peoples and made it temporarily more difficult for them to approach one another.” 2. The Helena Independent Helena Montana 6 DECEMBER 1931 THE HASKIN LETTER THE TASK OF HADDASSAH As a part of the educational work, the Hadassah has organized the Palestinian health Scouts among the school children. |
||||